Publication date: Available online 3 February 2018
Source:Magnetic Resonance Imaging
Author(s): Ravi Bansal, Bradley S. Peterson
Identifying regional effects of interest in MRI datasets usually entails testing a priori hypotheses across many thousands of brain voxels, requiring control for false positive findings in these multiple hypotheses testing. Recent studies have suggested that parametric statistical methods may have incorrectly modeled functional MRI data, thereby leading to higher false positive rates than their nominal rates. Nonparametric methods for statistical inference when conducting multiple statistical tests, in contrast, are thought to produce false positives at the nominal rate, which has thus led to the suggestion that previously reported studies should reanalyze their fMRI data using nonparametric tools.To understand better why parametric methods may yield excessive false positives, we assessed their performance when applied both to simulated datasets of 1D, 2D, and 3D Gaussian Random Fields (GRFs) and to 710 real-world, resting-state fMRI datasets. We showed that both the simulated 2D and 3D GRFs and the real-world data contain a small percentage (<6%) of very large clusters (on average 60 times larger than the average cluster size), which were not present in 1D GRFs. These unexpectedly large clusters were deemed statistically significant using parametric methods, leading to empirical familywise error rates (FWERs) as high as 65%: the high empirical FWERs were not a consequence of parametric methods failing to model spatial smoothness accurately, but rather of these very large clusters that are inherently present in smooth, high-dimensional random fields. In fact, when discounting these very large clusters, the empirical FWER for parametric methods was 3.24%. Furthermore, even an empirical FWER of 65% would yield on average less than one of those very large clusters in each brain-wide analysis. Nonparametric methods, in contrast, estimated distributions from those large clusters, and therefore, by construct rejected the large clusters as false positives at the nominal FWERs. Those rejected clusters were outlying values in the distribution of cluster size but cannot be distinguished from true positive findings without further analyses, including assessing whether fMRI signal in those regions correlates with other clinical, behavioral, or cognitive measures. Rejecting the large clusters, however, significantly reduced the statistical power of nonparametric methods in detecting true findings compared with parametric methods, which would have detected most true findings that are essential for making valid biological inferences in MRI data. Parametric analyses, in contrast, detected most true findings while generating relatively few false positives: on average, less than one of those very large clusters would be deemed a true finding in each brain-wide analysis. We therefore recommend the continued use of parametric methods that model nonstationary smoothness for cluster-level, familywise control of false positives, particularly when using a Cluster Defining Threshold of 2.5 or higher, and subsequently assessing rigorously the biological plausibility of the findings, even for large clusters. Finally, because nonparametric methods yielded a large reduction in statistical power to detect true positive findings, we conclude that the modest reduction in false positive findings that nonparametric analyses afford does not warrant a re-analysis of previously published fMRI studies using nonparametric techniques.
http://ift.tt/2EDoXeJ
Σφακιανάκης Αλέξανδρος
ΩτοΡινοΛαρυγγολόγος
Αναπαύσεως 5 Άγιος Νικόλαος
Κρήτη 72100
00302841026182
00306932607174
alsfakia@gmail.com
Αρχειοθήκη ιστολογίου
-
►
2023
(391)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (200)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (191)
-
►
2022
(2843)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (161)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (219)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (264)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (280)
-
►
2021
(5625)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (231)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (345)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (620)
-
►
2020
(2065)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (535)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (222)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (28)
-
►
2019
(9608)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (19)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (54)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (3791)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (3737)
-
▼
2018
(69720)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (3507)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (3851)
-
▼
Φεβρουαρίου
(8116)
-
▼
Φεβ 03
(397)
- Predicted environmental concentration and fate of ...
- Aqueous aggregation and stability of graphene nano...
- Organisms in wall ecosystems as biomonitors of met...
- Evaluating the evidence for motor-based interventi...
- Enhancing the comprehension of visual metaphors in...
- Sexuality issues and the voices of adults with int...
- Quality of life and habitual physical activity in ...
- Auditory temporal perceptual learning and transfer...
- Social validity in single-case research: A systema...
- Unravelling the role of fatty acid metabolism in c...
- Editorial Board
- Sympathetic innervation is essential for metabolic...
- Cluster-level statistical inference in fMRI datase...
- Single-injection ex ovo transplantation method for...
- In vivo two-photon imaging of motoneurons and adja...
- Targeted muscle reinnervation: advances and opport...
- Overexpression of YAP1 in EGFR mutant lung adenoca...
- The split hypoglossal nerve versus the cross-face ...
- Neural source dynamics of brain responses to conti...
- Simultaneous estimation of population receptive fi...
- Development of subcortical volumes across adolesce...
- Decoding the auditory brain with canonical compone...
- Neuroanatomical morphometric characterization of s...
- Direct electrophysiological evidence for the maint...
- White matter microstructural variability mediates ...
- Studying emotion theories through connectivity ana...
- Quantifying axonal responses in patient-specific m...
- Decoding intentions of self and others from fMRI a...
- Insight and inference for DVARS
- Combination of nano-material enrichment and dead-e...
- Thermo/pH dual-stimuli-responsive drug delivery fo...
- Competitive fluorescent pseudo-immunoassay exploit...
- Polydopamine-based functional composite particles ...
- Adsorption behavior of thorium on N,N,N′,N′-tetrao...
- A new tool for the evaluation of the analytical pr...
- Rapid determination of hydrophilic phenols in oliv...
- Development and application of molecularly imprint...
- Speciation of inorganic arsenic(III) and arsenic(V...
- The effect of loading carbon nanotubes onto chitos...
- Preparation of core-shell structured magnetic cova...
- Testing of nylon 6 nanofibers with different surfa...
- Adsorption studies of cadmium onto magnetic Fe3O4@...
- Electrodialytic extraction of anionic pharmaceutic...
- Aqueous biphasic systems formed by deep eutectic s...
- An interferometric imaging biosensor using weighte...
- A rhodamine-based fluorescent probe for colorimetr...
- Biochar alleviates the toxicity of imidacloprid an...
- Toxicity comparison of the shoreline cleaners Acce...
- Obesity surgery and risk of colorectal and other o...
- The placental immune response is dysregulated deve...
- Juvenile hormone and sesquiterpenoids in arthropod...
- Editorial Board
- Reliability of two pragmatic tools for assessing t...
- Manual therapy treatment for adolescent idiopathic...
- A strong linear relationship between Turns/Amplitu...
- The effects of short-term and long-term experience...
- Reliability of ultrasound shear-wave elastography ...
- Improving the test-retest and inter-rater reliabil...
- Occurrence of bifid median nerve in healthy and ca...
- STING-dependent interferon-λ1 induction in HT29 ce...
- Ki67 is an independent predictor of recurrence in ...
- Stereotactic Ablative Radiotherapy Versus Surgery ...
- L’observance du traitement par pression positive c...
- Étude de la prévalence du syndrome d’apnées obstru...
- Emphysème, vous avez dit emphysème ?
- Impact of pemetrexed on intracranial disease contr...
- A qualitative signature for predicting pathologica...
- Differentiation between radiation-induced brain in...
- Prognostic significance of pretreatment total lymp...
- Radiotherapy for prostate cancer – Does daily imag...
- Seeing Other Minds in 3D
- Antidepressant administration modulates stress-ind...
- Morphine antinociception on thermal sensitivity an...
- Food-induced reinforcement is abrogated by the gen...
- Exacerbation of sensorimotor dysfunction in mice d...
- Chronic amphetamine treatment affects collicular-d...
- NMDA receptors in the avian amygdala and the premo...
- Nicotine-enhanced Pavlovian conditioned approach i...
- Inequity aversion is observed in common marmosets ...
- Anxiety-like behavior and neuropeptide receptor ex...
- Editorial Board
- Downregulation of 5-hydroxytryptamine7 receptor in...
- Why should neuroscientists worry about iron? The e...
- How does the femoral cortex depend on bone shape? ...
- Editorial Board
- Table of Contents
- Information for Authors
- Masthead
- Seizure reductions outlast DBS explantation
- Contamination of estuaries from failing septic tan...
- Different calcification responses of two hermatypi...
- An injectable conductive hydrogel encapsulating pl...
- A bifunctional scaffold with CuFeSe2 nanocrystals ...
- Natural killer cell membrane infused biomimetic li...
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Predictors of internal mamma...
- Using the internal mammary artery as recipient art...
- Liposuction-assisted four pedicle based breast red...
- Influence of dressing application time after breas...
- Intraoperative imaging of lymphatic vessel using u...
- Invited commentary on jpras-d-17-00269
-
▼
Φεβ 03
(397)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (7758)
-
►
2017
(111579)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (7718)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (7549)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (10753)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (10529)
-
►
2016
(16402)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (7478)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (900)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (1250)
! # Ola via Alexandros G.Sfakianakis on Inoreader
Η λίστα ιστολογίων μου
Εγγραφή σε:
Σχόλια ανάρτησης (Atom)
Αρχειοθήκη ιστολογίου
-
►
2023
(391)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (200)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (191)
-
►
2022
(2843)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (161)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (219)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (264)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (280)
-
►
2021
(5625)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (231)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (345)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (620)
-
►
2020
(2065)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (535)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (222)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (28)
-
►
2019
(9608)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (19)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (54)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (3791)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (3737)
-
▼
2018
(69720)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (3507)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (3851)
-
▼
Φεβρουαρίου
(8116)
-
▼
Φεβ 03
(397)
- Predicted environmental concentration and fate of ...
- Aqueous aggregation and stability of graphene nano...
- Organisms in wall ecosystems as biomonitors of met...
- Evaluating the evidence for motor-based interventi...
- Enhancing the comprehension of visual metaphors in...
- Sexuality issues and the voices of adults with int...
- Quality of life and habitual physical activity in ...
- Auditory temporal perceptual learning and transfer...
- Social validity in single-case research: A systema...
- Unravelling the role of fatty acid metabolism in c...
- Editorial Board
- Sympathetic innervation is essential for metabolic...
- Cluster-level statistical inference in fMRI datase...
- Single-injection ex ovo transplantation method for...
- In vivo two-photon imaging of motoneurons and adja...
- Targeted muscle reinnervation: advances and opport...
- Overexpression of YAP1 in EGFR mutant lung adenoca...
- The split hypoglossal nerve versus the cross-face ...
- Neural source dynamics of brain responses to conti...
- Simultaneous estimation of population receptive fi...
- Development of subcortical volumes across adolesce...
- Decoding the auditory brain with canonical compone...
- Neuroanatomical morphometric characterization of s...
- Direct electrophysiological evidence for the maint...
- White matter microstructural variability mediates ...
- Studying emotion theories through connectivity ana...
- Quantifying axonal responses in patient-specific m...
- Decoding intentions of self and others from fMRI a...
- Insight and inference for DVARS
- Combination of nano-material enrichment and dead-e...
- Thermo/pH dual-stimuli-responsive drug delivery fo...
- Competitive fluorescent pseudo-immunoassay exploit...
- Polydopamine-based functional composite particles ...
- Adsorption behavior of thorium on N,N,N′,N′-tetrao...
- A new tool for the evaluation of the analytical pr...
- Rapid determination of hydrophilic phenols in oliv...
- Development and application of molecularly imprint...
- Speciation of inorganic arsenic(III) and arsenic(V...
- The effect of loading carbon nanotubes onto chitos...
- Preparation of core-shell structured magnetic cova...
- Testing of nylon 6 nanofibers with different surfa...
- Adsorption studies of cadmium onto magnetic Fe3O4@...
- Electrodialytic extraction of anionic pharmaceutic...
- Aqueous biphasic systems formed by deep eutectic s...
- An interferometric imaging biosensor using weighte...
- A rhodamine-based fluorescent probe for colorimetr...
- Biochar alleviates the toxicity of imidacloprid an...
- Toxicity comparison of the shoreline cleaners Acce...
- Obesity surgery and risk of colorectal and other o...
- The placental immune response is dysregulated deve...
- Juvenile hormone and sesquiterpenoids in arthropod...
- Editorial Board
- Reliability of two pragmatic tools for assessing t...
- Manual therapy treatment for adolescent idiopathic...
- A strong linear relationship between Turns/Amplitu...
- The effects of short-term and long-term experience...
- Reliability of ultrasound shear-wave elastography ...
- Improving the test-retest and inter-rater reliabil...
- Occurrence of bifid median nerve in healthy and ca...
- STING-dependent interferon-λ1 induction in HT29 ce...
- Ki67 is an independent predictor of recurrence in ...
- Stereotactic Ablative Radiotherapy Versus Surgery ...
- L’observance du traitement par pression positive c...
- Étude de la prévalence du syndrome d’apnées obstru...
- Emphysème, vous avez dit emphysème ?
- Impact of pemetrexed on intracranial disease contr...
- A qualitative signature for predicting pathologica...
- Differentiation between radiation-induced brain in...
- Prognostic significance of pretreatment total lymp...
- Radiotherapy for prostate cancer – Does daily imag...
- Seeing Other Minds in 3D
- Antidepressant administration modulates stress-ind...
- Morphine antinociception on thermal sensitivity an...
- Food-induced reinforcement is abrogated by the gen...
- Exacerbation of sensorimotor dysfunction in mice d...
- Chronic amphetamine treatment affects collicular-d...
- NMDA receptors in the avian amygdala and the premo...
- Nicotine-enhanced Pavlovian conditioned approach i...
- Inequity aversion is observed in common marmosets ...
- Anxiety-like behavior and neuropeptide receptor ex...
- Editorial Board
- Downregulation of 5-hydroxytryptamine7 receptor in...
- Why should neuroscientists worry about iron? The e...
- How does the femoral cortex depend on bone shape? ...
- Editorial Board
- Table of Contents
- Information for Authors
- Masthead
- Seizure reductions outlast DBS explantation
- Contamination of estuaries from failing septic tan...
- Different calcification responses of two hermatypi...
- An injectable conductive hydrogel encapsulating pl...
- A bifunctional scaffold with CuFeSe2 nanocrystals ...
- Natural killer cell membrane infused biomimetic li...
- LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Predictors of internal mamma...
- Using the internal mammary artery as recipient art...
- Liposuction-assisted four pedicle based breast red...
- Influence of dressing application time after breas...
- Intraoperative imaging of lymphatic vessel using u...
- Invited commentary on jpras-d-17-00269
-
▼
Φεβ 03
(397)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (7758)
-
►
2017
(111579)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (7718)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (7549)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (10753)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (10529)
-
►
2016
(16402)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (7478)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (900)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (1250)
Δεν υπάρχουν σχόλια:
Δημοσίευση σχολίου