Publication date: Available online 15 November 2017
Source:Cortex
Author(s): Constanze Hesse, Jutta Billino, Thomas Schenk
This commentary is the next in a chain of events. First, Striemer, Chapman, and Goodale (2009) argued, on the basis of a single case study testing a patient with hemianopia, that the primary visual cortex (V1) is not essential for successful obstacle avoidance behaviour. In the Cortex special issue on the "what and how-pathways", we (Ross, Schenk, Billino, MacLeod, & Hesse, 2016) examined six patients suffering from hemianopia and came to the conclusion that obstacle avoidance during reaching crucially relies on input from V1. Subsequently, Striemer, Chapman, and Goodale (2017) have claimed that we misunderstood their original report. Clearly it is time that we get to the bottom of these misunderstandings and explore opportunities for finding common ground.In the introduction of our study (Ross et al., 2016) we presented several reasons for why Striemer et al.'s (2009) single-case study requires corroboration from similar findings in a group of patients with damage to their occipital cortex but intact subcortical visual pathways. Striemer et al (2017, section 2, 1st paragraph). accept that our failure to replicate their original findings in a group of six patients (Ross et al., 2016) might constitute a serious challenge to the validity of their conclusions - but only if our study can be considered to be a fair test of their claims. In the rest of their commentary, Striemer et al. (2017) provide three main reasons for why our study does not provide such a fair test in their opinion. Firstly, they question the evidence from our patient study on the basis that our patients fail to fulfil the relevant conditions required for testing our hypothesis. Secondly, they suggest that we designed our experiments in ways that ensured a failure to replicate their original findings. Lastly, they argue that we misrepresented their position and attacked a straw man. In this commentary, we aim to demonstrate that (1) the disqualified evidence from our study can be recovered, (2) the methods used in our experiment have more redeeming aspects than granted; and finally, we assess the theoretical implications of Striemer et al.'s commentary for their original findings as well as for our study (3).
http://ift.tt/2zKnR0I
Σφακιανάκης Αλέξανδρος
ΩτοΡινοΛαρυγγολόγος
Αναπαύσεως 5 Άγιος Νικόλαος
Κρήτη 72100
00302841026182
00306932607174
alsfakia@gmail.com
Αρχειοθήκη ιστολογίου
-
►
2023
(391)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (200)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (191)
-
►
2022
(2843)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (161)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (219)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (264)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (280)
-
►
2021
(5625)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (231)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (345)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (620)
-
►
2020
(2065)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (535)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (222)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (28)
-
►
2019
(9608)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (19)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (54)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (3791)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (3737)
-
►
2018
(69720)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (3507)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (3851)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (8116)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (7758)
-
▼
2017
(111579)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (7718)
-
▼
Νοεμβρίου
(7424)
-
▼
Νοε 17
(335)
- The semantic system is involved in mathematical pr...
- Comparing multilayer brain networks between groups...
- Q-switched 532nm laser energy causes significant v...
- How well are reporting guidelines and trial regist...
- The expanding spectrum of clinical phenotypes asso...
- Response to ‘Clinical presentation of terbinafine-...
- Response to “IL-36 in hidradenitis suppurativa: Ev...
- Chronic sun exposure is associated with distinct h...
- Aprepitant improves refractory pruritus in primary...
- Q-switched 532nm laser energy causes significant v...
- How well are reporting guidelines and trial regist...
- The expanding spectrum of clinical phenotypes asso...
- Response to ‘Clinical presentation of terbinafine-...
- Response to “IL-36 in hidradenitis suppurativa: Ev...
- Chronic sun exposure is associated with distinct h...
- Aprepitant improves refractory pruritus in primary...
- Correction to: Pain, Psychological Comorbidities, ...
- Correction to: Pain, Psychological Comorbidities, ...
- Correction to: A bibliometric analysis of research...
- Allergen manufacturing and quality aspects for all...
- Copyright
- Contributors
- Contents
- Forthcoming Issues
- Castleman Disease
- Castleman Disease
- Epidemiology of Castleman Disease
- Castleman Disease Pathogenesis
- The Role of Interleukin-6 in Castleman Disease
- Pathology of Castleman Disease
- Diagnosis of Castleman Disease
- Unicentric Castleman Disease
- Treatment of Kaposi Sarcoma Herpesvirus–Associated...
- Treatment of Idiopathic Castleman Disease
- TAFRO Syndrome
- POEMS Syndrome
- POEMS Syndrome
- The Peripheral Neuropathies of POEMS Syndrome and ...
- 8 Cereals proteins
- 8 Cereals proteins
- Allergen manufacturing and quality aspects for all...
- Hypermethylated ZNF582 and PAX1 genes in oral scra...
- Patient-reported health outcomes in patients with ...
- Expression of the clock gene Rev-erbα in the brain...
- Sodium chloride pica causing recurrent nephrolithi...
- Metabolic Profile in Patients with Mild Obstructiv...
- Facilitating effects of Buyang Huanwu decoction on...
- Curcuzedoalide contributes to the cytotoxicity of ...
- The Challenge of Emerging Viruses
- The Unexpected Impact of Vaccines on Secondary Bac...
- Victimization and Human Immunodeficiency Virus-Rel...
- Patients with Spitz nevi in the Greek population: ...
- Acute and Recurrent Facial Pustulosis: A Unique Cl...
- A Slowly Developed Severe Cutaneous Adverse Reacti...
- Plantar Eumycetoma by Madurella mycetomatis in a h...
- Finding the needle in the haystack is teledermosco...
- Sodium chloride pica causing recurrent nephrolithi...
- Recognizing the haystack is the task of the primar...
- Editorial Board
- Editorial Board
- Table of Contents
- Optimal blood pressure decreases acute kidney inju...
- Bi-orifice approach to nasal intubation in childre...
- The effect of sevoflurane compared to propofol mai...
- A case of midazolam anaphylaxis during a pediatric...
- Anesthetic management of a patient with benign tra...
- Intermittent bilateral anterior sub-costal quadrat...
- A novel approach for performing ultrasound-guided ...
- Combined spinal epidural in a parturient with tine...
- Postpartum tubal ligation: A retrospective review ...
- Surgeon assisted quadratus lumborum block – ‘Gaura...
- Anesthetic management for retrieval of a large asp...
- Reversal of trend in near infrared spectroscopy [N...
- Strategies to prevent ischemic optic neuropathy fo...
- Medicaid insurance as primary payer predicts incre...
- Incidence of complications in the post-anesthesia ...
- Measuring satisfaction and anesthesia related outc...
- Paraneuraxial Nerve Blocks: A well-defined novel t...
- Emergency surgery in a newborn patient with severe...
- Postpartum infective endocarditis with Enterococcu...
- Two Scientific Awards for papers published in Slee...
- Editorial Board
- Effect of laser activated bleaching on the chemica...
- New roles and controls of mast cells
- Recent advances in inflammasome biology
- Type I interferon-mediated autoinflammation and au...
- Mechanisms of propofol attenuation of ketamine-ind...
- Lumbar Spine Anatomy in Women Sustaining Unintenti...
- Postpartum infective endocarditis with Enterococcu...
- Using Citrus aurantifolia essential oil for the po...
- Intrapartum assessment of fetal well-being
- Treatment withdrawal and end-of-life care in the i...
- Prehabilitation
- Anaesthesia for head and neck cancer surgery
- Principles of resource allocation in critical care
- Treatment withdrawal and end-of-life care in the i...
- Prehabilitation
- Anaesthesia for head and neck cancer surgery
- You Will Never Walk Alone: A Simulation Experience...
- Enhanced Recovery After Surgery: Current Controver...
-
▼
Νοε 17
(335)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (7549)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (10753)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (10529)
-
►
2016
(16402)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (7478)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (900)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (1250)
! # Ola via Alexandros G.Sfakianakis on Inoreader
Η λίστα ιστολογίων μου
Εγγραφή σε:
Σχόλια ανάρτησης (Atom)
Αρχειοθήκη ιστολογίου
-
►
2023
(391)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (200)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (191)
-
►
2022
(2843)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (161)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (219)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (264)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (280)
-
►
2021
(5625)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (231)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (345)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (620)
-
►
2020
(2065)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (535)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (222)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (28)
-
►
2019
(9608)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (19)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (54)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (3791)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (3737)
-
►
2018
(69720)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (3507)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (3851)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (8116)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (7758)
-
▼
2017
(111579)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (7718)
-
▼
Νοεμβρίου
(7424)
-
▼
Νοε 17
(335)
- The semantic system is involved in mathematical pr...
- Comparing multilayer brain networks between groups...
- Q-switched 532nm laser energy causes significant v...
- How well are reporting guidelines and trial regist...
- The expanding spectrum of clinical phenotypes asso...
- Response to ‘Clinical presentation of terbinafine-...
- Response to “IL-36 in hidradenitis suppurativa: Ev...
- Chronic sun exposure is associated with distinct h...
- Aprepitant improves refractory pruritus in primary...
- Q-switched 532nm laser energy causes significant v...
- How well are reporting guidelines and trial regist...
- The expanding spectrum of clinical phenotypes asso...
- Response to ‘Clinical presentation of terbinafine-...
- Response to “IL-36 in hidradenitis suppurativa: Ev...
- Chronic sun exposure is associated with distinct h...
- Aprepitant improves refractory pruritus in primary...
- Correction to: Pain, Psychological Comorbidities, ...
- Correction to: Pain, Psychological Comorbidities, ...
- Correction to: A bibliometric analysis of research...
- Allergen manufacturing and quality aspects for all...
- Copyright
- Contributors
- Contents
- Forthcoming Issues
- Castleman Disease
- Castleman Disease
- Epidemiology of Castleman Disease
- Castleman Disease Pathogenesis
- The Role of Interleukin-6 in Castleman Disease
- Pathology of Castleman Disease
- Diagnosis of Castleman Disease
- Unicentric Castleman Disease
- Treatment of Kaposi Sarcoma Herpesvirus–Associated...
- Treatment of Idiopathic Castleman Disease
- TAFRO Syndrome
- POEMS Syndrome
- POEMS Syndrome
- The Peripheral Neuropathies of POEMS Syndrome and ...
- 8 Cereals proteins
- 8 Cereals proteins
- Allergen manufacturing and quality aspects for all...
- Hypermethylated ZNF582 and PAX1 genes in oral scra...
- Patient-reported health outcomes in patients with ...
- Expression of the clock gene Rev-erbα in the brain...
- Sodium chloride pica causing recurrent nephrolithi...
- Metabolic Profile in Patients with Mild Obstructiv...
- Facilitating effects of Buyang Huanwu decoction on...
- Curcuzedoalide contributes to the cytotoxicity of ...
- The Challenge of Emerging Viruses
- The Unexpected Impact of Vaccines on Secondary Bac...
- Victimization and Human Immunodeficiency Virus-Rel...
- Patients with Spitz nevi in the Greek population: ...
- Acute and Recurrent Facial Pustulosis: A Unique Cl...
- A Slowly Developed Severe Cutaneous Adverse Reacti...
- Plantar Eumycetoma by Madurella mycetomatis in a h...
- Finding the needle in the haystack is teledermosco...
- Sodium chloride pica causing recurrent nephrolithi...
- Recognizing the haystack is the task of the primar...
- Editorial Board
- Editorial Board
- Table of Contents
- Optimal blood pressure decreases acute kidney inju...
- Bi-orifice approach to nasal intubation in childre...
- The effect of sevoflurane compared to propofol mai...
- A case of midazolam anaphylaxis during a pediatric...
- Anesthetic management of a patient with benign tra...
- Intermittent bilateral anterior sub-costal quadrat...
- A novel approach for performing ultrasound-guided ...
- Combined spinal epidural in a parturient with tine...
- Postpartum tubal ligation: A retrospective review ...
- Surgeon assisted quadratus lumborum block – ‘Gaura...
- Anesthetic management for retrieval of a large asp...
- Reversal of trend in near infrared spectroscopy [N...
- Strategies to prevent ischemic optic neuropathy fo...
- Medicaid insurance as primary payer predicts incre...
- Incidence of complications in the post-anesthesia ...
- Measuring satisfaction and anesthesia related outc...
- Paraneuraxial Nerve Blocks: A well-defined novel t...
- Emergency surgery in a newborn patient with severe...
- Postpartum infective endocarditis with Enterococcu...
- Two Scientific Awards for papers published in Slee...
- Editorial Board
- Effect of laser activated bleaching on the chemica...
- New roles and controls of mast cells
- Recent advances in inflammasome biology
- Type I interferon-mediated autoinflammation and au...
- Mechanisms of propofol attenuation of ketamine-ind...
- Lumbar Spine Anatomy in Women Sustaining Unintenti...
- Postpartum infective endocarditis with Enterococcu...
- Using Citrus aurantifolia essential oil for the po...
- Intrapartum assessment of fetal well-being
- Treatment withdrawal and end-of-life care in the i...
- Prehabilitation
- Anaesthesia for head and neck cancer surgery
- Principles of resource allocation in critical care
- Treatment withdrawal and end-of-life care in the i...
- Prehabilitation
- Anaesthesia for head and neck cancer surgery
- You Will Never Walk Alone: A Simulation Experience...
- Enhanced Recovery After Surgery: Current Controver...
-
▼
Νοε 17
(335)
- ► Σεπτεμβρίου (7549)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (10753)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (10529)
-
►
2016
(16402)
- ► Δεκεμβρίου (7478)
- ► Φεβρουαρίου (900)
- ► Ιανουαρίου (1250)
Δεν υπάρχουν σχόλια:
Δημοσίευση σχολίου